57 Homemade Ice Cream Maker Recipes - The Crafty Blog Stalker (2024)

Are you looking to satisfy your sweet tooth and beat the heat at the same time? Look no further than homemade ice cream!

With an ice cream maker, you can create endless flavor combinations and customize your ice cream to your liking.

To help you get started on your ice cream making journey, we’ve compiled a list of 57 of the best recipes for homemade ice cream.

From classic ice cream recipes like vanilla and chocolate to unique combinations like lavender honey and strawberry cheesecake, these recipes are sure to impress your taste buds and wow your entire family.

So dust off your ice cream maker and let’s make our own ice cream!

Ice Cream Maker I Use:

I recently got my first Ice Cream Machine and I absolutely love it. It is a Hamilton Beach 4qt.

For best results, follow the manufacturer's instructions on churn time, no matter what brand of ice cream maker you are using.

1. Best Homemade Chocolate Ice Cream from Joy Food Sunshine

This chocolate ice cream recipe is rich, creamy, and chocolatey. It's easy to make with only 7 ingredients, including whole milk and two types of chocolate. It tastes just as good as any ice cream shop. Your ice cream bowl will thank you.

2. Biscoff Ice Cream from Katie's Cucina

I've concocted a mind-blowing ice cream recipe featuring Biscoff cookies. Brace yourself for a delightful treat that will sweep you off your feet, especially if you have a sweet tooth for buttery cookies. Get ready to indulge in this heavenly ice cream recipe!

3. Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe from Alyona's Cooking

This delicious creamy ice cream is incredibly easy to make with a no-cook egg custard. Whipping the eggs to a creamy consistency gives you the best vanilla ice cream without all the extra work! A perfect ice cream base to add your favorite toppings.

Go to the Recipe

4. Bubble Gum Ice Cream Homemade from More Minutes

I have replicated the classic bubble gum ice cream that takes you back in time! Not only did I capture its original vibrant hue, but I also made sure to infuse it with the luxurious and smooth flavor of homemade ice cream.

5. Pralines and Cream from Ice Cream from Scratch

Indulge in the delectable combination of freshly candied pecans, creamy vanilla ice cream, and swirls of gooey caramel with this Homemade Pralines and Cream Ice Cream recipe.

Go to the Recipe

6. Caramel Sugar Cone Frozen Yogurt from Kleinworth & Co

Indulge in a caramel lover's dream with our Caramel Sugar Cone Frozen Yogurt! This easy, no-churn frozen yogurt recipe is packed with crushed sugar cones and lusciously swirled with caramel for the ultimate sweet treat.

7. Strawberry Sorbet from Culinary Shades

Easily whip up a batch of vegan, gluten-free Strawberry sorbet in minutes with an ice cream maker. Just blend, stir, and freeze for a refreshing and fruity treat!

8. Four Ingredient Chocolate Cookies 'n' Cream Ice Cream from Two Peas and Their Pod

Celebrate summer with this 4 Ingredient Chocolate Cookies 'n' Cream Ice Cream mixture that will satisfy your sweet tooth and keep you cool during the hot months. Just freeze and enjoy!

9. Honey Lavender Ice Cream from Lady Behind the Curtain

Make a gourmet floral treat with Lavender flowers for Spring or Summer events like tea, a bridal shower, a baby shower, or a lady's luncheon. This homemade ice cream is light and refreshing!

Go to the Recipe

10. Creamy Coconut Pineapple Ice Cream from Daily Dish Recipes

Devour the taste of summer with our Creamy Coconut Pineapple Ice Cream. This heavenly blend of coconut and pineapple is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and transport you to a tropical paradise!

11. Butter Pecan Ice Cream from The Recipe Rebel

You can make this rich and creamy Butter Pecan Ice Cream in just 25 minutes with only 7 ingredients! Enjoy the delicious combination of brown sugar, vanilla flavor, and toasty pecans.

12. Dark Chocolate Ice Cream from Bless This Mess

Once you've tasted our homemade dark chocolate ice cream, you'll never want to settle for store-bought again! It's decadent creaminess and luxurious flavor are simply unmatched.

13. Oreo Cheesecake Ice Cream from Culinary Shades

Love cookies and cream ice cream? Then you'll definitely enjoy this 5-ingredient Oreo cheesecake ice cream made with a cream cheese base. No cooking and dairy-free, just use your ice cream maker!

14. Double Thin Mint Ice Cream from Big Bear's Wife

Enjoy no-churn Thin Mint Ice Cream made with Girl Scout Cookies! No ice cream maker is needed for this refreshing, minty treat. Try it today!

15. Superman Ice Cream by Ice Cream from Scratch

Make a super fun and colorful ice cream flavor that kids will love - Superman Ice Cream! With this homemade no-churn recipe, you and your kids can make it together and enjoy the fruity flavors.

17. Homemade Cherry Garcia Ice Cream from Served from Scratch

Make creamy and dreamy Homemade Cherry Garcia Ice Cream with fresh summer cherries! Just pop it in the freezer when done churning for a nice hard ice cream.

18. Espresso Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips from Table for Two

Make your own rich and creamy Espresso Chocolate Chip Ice Cream in just 5 mins! With only 3 ingredients - espresso powder, heavy cream, and sweetened condensed milk - you can create this delectable treat. Don't hesitate, this is the best ice cream!

19. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream from Handle the Heat

This egg-free Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream recipe is incredibly easy, creamy, and flavorful thanks to a few secret ingredients. It's even better than expensive store-bought brands!

20. Fresh Peach Ice Cream from Bless This Mess

Enjoy a cool summer treat with our Fresh Peach Ice Cream made from ripe, juicy peaches! With just heavy cream, sugar, and vanilla, you can easily whip up this homemade ice cream that's both easy and delicious.

22. Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream from Noble Pig

Try Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream - a creamy cherry-flavored treat that's easy to make without custard. Chill your ingredients, churn them in your ice cream maker, and indulge in your new favorite dessert!

24. Homemade Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream from Amanda's Cookin'

Treat yourself to a dreamy and ultra-delicious dessert with this homemade Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream recipe. You'll love the smooth and creamy texture of this indulgent treat!

26. Peanut Butter Ice Cream from Recipe Girl

Make your own Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream right at home with this easy recipe! This classic flavor is one of the most popular and now you can enjoy it anytime you want.

28. Root Beer Ice Cream from Amanda's Cookin'

I experimented with some flavors and created this root beer ice cream using root beer extract from my pantry. It's inspired by the classic root beer float, a beloved favorite for many years. Enjoy the taste of root beer and ice cream in one delicious treat!

30. Soda Pop Ice Cream Recipe from Leigh Anne Wilkes

You can transform your favorite soda into a delightful ice cream treat with just 3 simple ingredients! This recipe is both easy and scrumptious.

32. Vanilla Blackberry Jam Ice Cream from Amanda's Cookin'

This ice cream recipe uses jam or preserves, but fresh blackberries cooked with sugar and sieved can also be used to make homemade jam. If you have too many jars of different flavored jams in your refrigerator like me, try using them in this recipe.

34. Snickerdoodle Ice Cream from Recipe Girl

If you're a huge fan of Snickerdoodle cookies like me, you'll definitely agree that Snickerdoodle Ice Cream is one of the greatest ice cream flavors ever made!

38. Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream from Ashlee Marie

I adore pumpkin pie in every form - pie, cheesecake, warm drink, and especially this creamy pumpkin ice cream! It's amazing on its own or topped with extra pie crust shards. I'm thinking of trying to make a waffle cone with the pie crust dough next time!

40. Fresh Lemon Ice Cream from The View from Great Island

Enjoy the refreshing and unique taste of Fresh Lemon Ice Cream made with plenty of fresh lemon juice. This homemade ice cream is unlike any other and offers a zesty and tangy citrus flavor that you won't find in store-bought varieties.

42. Cookies and Cream Ice Cream from Homemade Hoopla

Homemade eggless Cookies and Cream ice cream that can be tailored to your preference with your choice of cookie.

43. Salted Caramel Pecan Ice Cream from Like Mother Like Daughter

Indulge in the rich and creamy goodness of Salted Caramel Pecan Ice Cream - featuring a salted caramel custard base, swirled with even more salted caramel and toasted pecans throughout. It's a truly delicious treat.

44. Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream from Handle the Heat

We absolutely love this Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream recipe because it's bursting with fruity, tangy, and sweet flavors - just like the best strawberry cheesecake turned into a scoop of ice cream. It's simply heavenly!

45. Maple Walnut Ice Cream from House of Nash Eats

Maple Walnut Ice Cream with a custard base made from real maple syrup and toasted walnut pieces in every bite is an old-fashioned classic flavor found mainly in ice cream shops and boardwalks. This flavor deserves to be brought back into the spotlight!

46. Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream from Beyond Frosting

This Homemade Pumpkin Ice Cream is the real deal - rich, creamy, and topped with graham cracker crumbs. Made with a thick custard base, pumpkin puree, and pumpkin spice, it's even better than store-bought ice cream.

47. Peach Crumble Ice Cream from Baking a Moment

Love peach crumble? You'll adore this ice cream recipe! Brown butter elevates the vanilla custard, complementing the juicy peaches beautifully. Topped with a cinnamon-spiced streusel, it's a late-summer dream come true.

48. Banana Pudding Ice Cream by Ice Cream from Scratch

Similar to the classic old-fashioned pudding dessert, Banana Pudding Ice Cream is a delectable treat with real bananas and crunchy vanilla wafer cookies blended in for a creamy and delicious taste.

49. Lemonade Ice Cream from I Heart Naptime

Combining two favorite summertime treats, lemonade and ice cream, lemon ice cream is the perfect refreshing, bright, and delicious summer treat.

50. Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt from Chocolate Covered Katie

With only 5 ingredients, this peanut butter frozen yogurt is a smooth, rich, and creamy healthy treat that's ideal for beating the heat on a hot day.

51. Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream from Creations by Kara

This homemade Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream is incredibly luscious and words cannot fully capture its deliciousness. You must try this recipe!

52. Best Strawberry Ice Cream from A Latte Food

Enjoy a creamy and dreamy spring or summer dessert with this Homemade Strawberry Ice Cream made from fresh strawberries using an old-fashioned recipe.

53. Chunky Monkey Ice Cream by Made From Scratch

Make your own version of the famous Ben and Jerry's Chunky Monkey Ice Cream with this easy homemade recipe.

54. Jello Sherbet Ice Cream from Smart School House

This fruity Jello sherbet ice cream has a smooth, silky, and creamy texture that rivals store-bought brands, while still delivering a deliciously fruity flavor.

55. Watermelon Ice Cream from Recipes to Nourish

The best way to indulge in a delicious summer treat is with this easy, 7-ingredient Creamy Real Food Watermelon Ice Cream recipe made from fresh ingredients.

56. Pineapple Ice Cream by Ice Cream from Scratch

Homemade Pineapple Ice Cream is a perfect tropical treat for hot summer days. Made with simple ingredients and churned with an ice cream maker, it's a great recipe to learn how to make ice cream.

57. Dark Chocolate Fudge Ice Cream from It's Always Autumn

I prefer my ice cream to be dark and fudgy, unlike the barely brown chocolate ice cream found in grocery stores. For me, ice cream should be rich, creamy, and absolutely amazing.

Our Baking Essential List:

• For baking casseroles, we use Glass Baking Dishes. I especially like the dishes with lids so leftovers can be transferred straight to the fridge.
• Silicone Kitchenware is my favorite because they don't scratch my cookware and are super easy to clean!
• To prepare all of those ingredients a Glass Cutting Board is a must. We even keep ours on our counter at all times.
• This Knife Set will also become your favorite! They cut beautifully and with the hollow design of the knife, food doesn't stick to the blade.